Woman reading in a striped hammock outdoors

Unlimited PTO Policy: Free Template, Rules, Pros & Cons

Handbooks Team
Handbooks Team
April 22, 2026

(Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered legal advice.)

In 2020, a California appeals court ruled that an employer owed former employees pay for unused vacation, even though their time off was supposedly unlimited. In McPherson v. EF Intercultural Foundation, the policy was never put in writing and came with an unspoken cap, so the court treated the time off as earned vacation that had to be paid out when the employees left.

While unlimited PTO policies are a popular perk, they can be misunderstood—and misunderstood benefits can lead to problems, especially if you’re located in a state like California, where employers are required to pay out an employee’s accrued vacation time upon separation. If three weeks is the limit your employees believe in despite your unlimited PTO policy, they might hold you to that—and you don’t want to find out about it when they leave.

In this article, we’ll explain how accrued PTO and unlimited PTO policies differ, as well as the pros and cons, legal implications (like the payout requirement in California!), best practices and more. We’ll also include a free unlimited PTO policy template for you to use as a starting point when drafting your own.

What is an unlimited PTO policy?

An unlimited PTO policy (also known as a flexible or discretionary time off policy) allows eligible employees to request manager-approved paid time off as needed to ensure adequate coverage, as long as work responsibilities are being met, without accruing PTO or earning a specific number of PTO days. Unlike an accrued PTO policy, there’s typically no payout associated with an unlimited PTO policy since employees aren’t accruing PTO.

How does unlimited PTO differ from accrued PTO?

With an accrued PTO policy, employees typically accrue a certain amount of PTO (e.g., vacation, personal days, sick days, etc.) each pay period and can use that PTO for any purpose (if permitted) up until a certain point in time (again, if permitted). Depending on your state’s laws and your PTO policy, employees may be entitled to a payout for unused, accrued PTO when they leave your company.

With an unlimited PTO policy, on the other hand, employees don’t accrue PTO—they simply request it when they need it, subject to manager approval. Since employees aren’t accruing PTO, there’s typically no payout upon separation. That said, it’s important to note that unlimited PTO policies must still comply with paid sick leave laws (where applicable), which can affect how you draft your policy and whether or not employees are entitled to a payout.

Unlimited PTOAccrued PTO
How it worksTime off as needed, with approvalEarned over time, used from a balance
BalanceNone, no set maximumGrows as employees work
PayoutUsually none, if truly unlimitedRequired in states like California
TrackingFor sick leave and FMLAFor accruals, sick leave and FMLA
Best fitResults-based, often exempt rolesHourly and shift-based roles

Accrued PTO vs. unlimited PTO

Whether you offer unlimited PTO or a more traditional PTO program, it’s important to have a written PTO policy to avoid misunderstandings between you and your employees.

There’s no federal law that requires employers to offer paid vacation to their employees, so it’s up to you and your employees to come to an agreement about PTO. The U.S. Department of Labor leaves vacation pay up to the agreement between employers and employees.

Here’s a quick look at the pros and cons of unlimited PTO compared to accrued PTO.

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Time off as needed (with approval)Some employees don’t take as much PTO
No accrued PTO to keep track ofInconsistent approvals can seem unfair
No accrued PTO to pay out in many statesHarder to police abuse or long absences
Attractive benefit when recruitingMay not work for hourly or shift roles
Fits high-trust, results-based jobsStill need tracking for FMLA, sick leave

That said, PTO tracking can also be useful to help managers make sure employees are taking enough PTO.

When unlimited PTO might make sense

Unlimited PTO can be a great way to show employees you trust them to manage their own time and energy. It can work particularly well for exempt positions that are focused on employee performance instead of the number of hours worked.

It’s important to keep in mind that even if you don’t track accrued PTO, you may still be required to track other kinds of leave (such as FMLA leave or paid sick leave, depending on where your business is located).

But unlimited PTO isn’t necessarily a good fit for all businesses or employees. In fact, it may not be the best option if you have non-exempt employees that work shifts or hourly positions where coverage is an issue. (“Take what you need” policies can lead to gaps in coverage and scheduling challenges.) Many employers reserve unlimited PTO for exempt employees and offer PTO that accrues for all other employees.

Is unlimited PTO a trap?

Employees may view unlimited PTO as a trap for the following reasons:

  • Employees may end up taking less PTO since there’s no accrued amount to encourage them to take time off.
  • Approval can vary depending on who an employee’s manager is. Co-workers can have vastly different experiences taking PTO depending on their manager’s management style.
  • Employees don’t receive compensation for PTO when they leave since it didn’t accrue.

For employers, unlimited PTO can be a trap when it’s not unlimited in practice. PTO policies that aren’t applied consistently can expose employers to charges of unfair or discriminatory practices. And in some states, such as California, PTO policies that aren’t unlimited in practice may be subject to payout requirements as accrued vacation.

For employees and employers to avoid feeling trapped by unlimited PTO policies, employers should:

  • Adopt clear written policies.
  • Consistently apply PTO policies.
  • Encourage employees to take PTO.

The remainder of this guide will walk you through how to do exactly that.

Even though unlimited PTO policies sidestep some employment laws (like those requiring vacation payout), they’re still subject to other employment laws. Before you implement an unlimited PTO policy, keep these potential legal landmines in mind.

Payout at separation and the California risk

In states like California that require employers to pay out accrued vacation when employees separate, employers with truly unlimited PTO policies shouldn’t have payout issues since employees aren’t accruing PTO. According to the California Labor Commissioner’s vacation FAQ, vacation and PTO that employees earn is considered wages. So the question employers should be asking themselves is whether their employees are actually earning PTO.

In McPherson v. EF Intercultural Foundation (2020), for example, a California court determined that an employer’s supposedly-unlimited PTO policy wasn’t truly unlimited in practice and was, therefore, subject to California’s vacation payout laws. So if you have an unlimited PTO policy, tread carefully to ensure it’s unlimited in practice, too. Here are some best practices:

  • Adopt clear written policies.
  • Specify that PTO doesn’t accrue and isn’t earned, and avoid having managers refer to PTO as such.
  • Have managers base PTO decisions on business needs (e.g., coverage, fairness among employees, workload) and not on some imaginary PTO accrual amount.
  • Track PTO taken for recordkeeping purposes, but make sure this doesn’t function as a cap or accrual amount.

FMLA and extended absences

FMLA leave isn’t PTO, so an unlimited PTO policy shouldn’t cover situations that call for FMLA leave (such as for your employee’s or a family member’s serious health condition) or other extended absences (such as parental leave or disability leave).

Many (but not all) states and cities require you to offer paid sick leave. While unlimited PTO policies can comply with many paid sick leave laws, your policy must:

  • Allow your employees to use PTO for all the reasons covered by your state or city’s paid sick leave law.
  • Limit the documentation and advance notice your employees can be required to provide to the maximum your state or city’s paid sick leave law allows.
  • Prevent your managers from denying protected sick leave. Remember, your managers can turn down an employee’s request for a week of PTO to go to the beach during product launch week — but they can’t turn down an employee’s request for one day of protected sick leave. Make this clear in your unlimited PTO policy and educate your managers!
  • Follow any requirements your state or city’s paid sick leave law has for listing paid sick leave balances on pay statements (in most cases, indicating that an employee’s sick leave balance is “unlimited” will suffice).

Some states also offer paid family and medical leave programs. Depending on how your state’s program works, you may need to account for it in your unlimited PTO policy and make sure your managers know to follow your leave of absence procedures (rather than your unlimited PTO policy) for any absences covered by your state’s paid family and medical leave program.

Tracking time off

Even if you implement an unlimited PTO policy, you may still need to keep track of your employees’ time off in certain situations (such as to comply with paid sick leave laws or FMLA).

Switching from accrued PTO to unlimited PTO

If you currently offer PTO that accrues over time and you’re thinking about switching to an unlimited PTO policy, check out our article on accrued PTO to learn about what you’ll need to do with any PTO your employees have already accrued (spoiler alert: in “payout” states, you’ll likely either need to pay your employees out for their accrued PTO when you implement your new unlimited PTO policy, continue to offer accrued PTO as a “legacy” benefit to employees who had accrued PTO before you implemented your unlimited PTO policy (and outline in writing how this “legacy” accrued PTO can be used), or otherwise honor the PTO your employees have already accrued).

Be sure to speak with an attorney before switching from an accrued PTO policy to an unlimited PTO policy, especially if you have employees in payout states (like California!). As with any change to your employee handbook policies, be sure to:

  • Provide written notice to your employees about the new unlimited PTO policy.
  • Clearly explain in your policy how PTO requests will be made and who will approve or deny them.
  • Train your managers on any criteria they should consider when approving or denying PTO requests.
  • Have your employees sign an acknowledgment that they received and had the opportunity to review your new unlimited PTO policy.

Eligibility: exempt and non-exempt employees

While unlimited PTO plans are most common for exempt employees (whose jobs are often defined more by output than hours worked), some employers offer them to non-exempt employees as well. Accrued PTO may be easier to administer for hourly employees, though, given coverage and timekeeping considerations.

Whatever type of PTO plan you have, eligibility requirements should be even-handed and job-related. Employees are likely to raise fairness concerns if some employees in the same position have unlimited PTO while others don’t.

How to create an unlimited PTO policy

To develop an effective unlimited PTO policy, consider the following:

  1. Eligibility: Which positions are eligible for unlimited PTO? Which employees accrue PTO under a separate policy?
  2. PTO requests: How much advance notice is required? What criteria will supervisors use to determine whether to approve a request?
  3. PTO limits: Are there certain times of year when planned vacation will be limited (blackout dates)? Are there certain days the entire company will be closed (shutdown days)? Is there a recommended minimum amount of PTO employees should take each year (e.g., 15 days)? If so, will supervisors follow up with employees who haven’t taken at least that much?
  4. Paid sick leave: How will the policy satisfy paid sick leave laws? How will the employer keep track of employees’ sick leave and FMLA leave?
  5. Separation from employment: If an employee leaves the company, will she be entitled to any payout? Generally, the answer is no if she was subject to a true unlimited PTO policy (since, by definition, she would not have accrued any PTO).

The sample unlimited PTO policy below addresses each of these topics.

Tips for success

Employees are more likely to take advantage of unlimited PTO – and feel comfortable doing so – if there are clear expectations. Consider including the following in your policy:

  • A suggested minimum amount of PTO: As mentioned above, you may want to suggest that employees take at least a certain amount of PTO each year. Managers can check in with employees who have not taken the suggested minimum to see if everything’s okay.
  • Guidelines for PTO requests: Employees should know how much advance notice to give when requesting PTO (e.g., two weeks’ notice for a one-week absence). Managers should understand what criteria they should use when deciding whether to approve PTO requests and how they should handle situations in which multiple employees request time off on the same days.
  • Blackout dates: Some businesses have particularly busy times of year when planned vacation may be limited. If so, let employees know in advance. (Note that employees’ legally protected sick leave rights aren’t affected.)
  • FMLA and other leave: If an employee will be out for an extended period of time for a qualifying FMLA reason (e.g., a serious health condition or to bond with a new child), have the absence processed in accordance with your FMLA, disability leave or other leave policy rather than your PTO policy.
  • Company shutdowns: Consider having companywide shutdown days (e.g., the week between Christmas and New Year’s) or “recharge” days sprinkled throughout the year so all employees – including those who would otherwise be reluctant to take PTO – get a breather.

Is there such a thing as too much PTO?

There’s no magic number, and employers shouldn’t have a secret one (which could cause California to consider the PTO accrued vacation). Instead, managers should consider business needs, including coverage and fairness to other employees. If an employee’s frequent absences are adversely affecting his performance or his coworkers’ performance, address the situation the same way you’d handle any other employee performance issue – and make sure you’re holding all employees to the same standard.

Long absences for a serious health condition or a new child are a different matter. Those belong in your leave of absence policies, not your PTO policy.

Free unlimited PTO policy template

Copy and adapt this sample unlimited PTO policy. Replace the bracketed text, delete the options that don’t apply to your company, and have an employment attorney review the final version.


Flexible Time Off (Unlimited PTO)

Eligibility. [Regular full-time exempt employees] are eligible for flexible time off. [Other employees accrue PTO under the PTO policy.]

How it works. Eligible employees do not accrue or earn paid time off. Instead, you may take paid time off as needed for vacation, personal matters, illness and other reasons, subject to approval as described below.

Minimum time off. [Company Name] encourages eligible employees to take at least [15] days off each year, in addition to company holidays, to rest and recharge.

Requesting time off. Request planned time off through [system] in advance. For absences of [five] or more consecutive workdays, make your request at least [two weeks] in advance so that [Company Name] can ensure adequate coverage. Your manager will approve or deny your request based on business needs, coverage and fairness. Notify your manager as soon as practicable if you’re unable to work because of illness or another unforeseeable circumstance.

Extended absences. Absences for an eligible employee’s or family member’s serious health condition, or for parental leave, that last longer than [five] consecutive workdays will be approved or denied pursuant to [Company Name]’s applicable leave of absence policies (including, where applicable, in accordance with FMLA).

Blackout periods. [Company Name] may limit or prohibit planned (i.e., non-emergency) flexible time off during certain times of the year (“blackout periods”), for reasons such as peaks in business activity or excessive use of flexible time off by members of a work group or department. [Company Name] will not impose blackout periods with regard to sick and safe leave or other absences to the extent protected by applicable law.

Sick and safe leave. Eligible employees may use flexible time off for any purpose for which paid sick and safe leave may be used under applicable law. [Company Name] will not deny such absences and will administer them in accordance with applicable sick and safe leave laws.

Recordkeeping. [Company Name] tracks flexible time off taken by eligible employees solely for administrative purposes and to ensure compliance with applicable leave of absence laws. Such tracking does not result in a “balance” of available flexible time off and does not limit eligible employees’ flexible time off.

No accrual or payout. Because flexible time off is not accrued or earned by eligible employees, there is no flexible time off “balance” that is paid out upon an employee’s termination of employment, except to the extent required by applicable law.

Changes. [Company Name] may modify or terminate the flexible time off policy at any time, effective upon notice to employees, subject to applicable law.

Questions. If you have questions about flexible time off, contact [HR contact].


Tips for customizing the template

  • Eligibility: If hourly employees will keep accruing PTO, keep the second bracketed sentence and make sure your PTO policy covers them.
  • Minimum time off: Treat the 15 days as an example. Pick a number your managers will actively encourage, not just tolerate.

Common unlimited PTO mistakes to avoid

Other potential pitfalls of unlimited PTO include:

  1. Not keeping track of time off: Even with an unlimited PTO policy, you may still be required to keep track of employee time off for purposes of complying with FMLA and paid sick leave laws. As long as these records aren’t used to establish a PTO balance, keeping track of PTO for administrative purposes shouldn’t create issues for your company.
  2. Claiming your PTO policy is unlimited when it isn’t: If your policy sets a cap on PTO or requires additional approval after a certain number of days or weeks, your “unlimited” PTO policy may not be so unlimited after all. In states like California, this could result in your company owing employees compensation for accrued and unused vacation upon separation from employment.
  3. Failing to set a minimum expectation: Research shows that employees with unlimited PTO take less PTO than employees with traditional PTO policies. To ensure employees are getting adequate time off to prevent burnout and promote employee well-being, set an expectation as to the minimum amount of PTO employees should take and hold managers accountable for making sure employees are getting the PTO they need.
  4. Allowing managers to establish their own guidelines for PTO: To avoid claims of disparate treatment or discrimination, it’s important that managers not be allowed to develop their own criteria for approving or denying PTO requests. Create objective criteria for approving or denying PTO requests and make sure managers are aware of and following those criteria.
  5. Denying legally protected sick leave: While managers may consider team coverage and other legitimate business reasons when deciding whether to approve or deny planned vacation time, they cannot do so when denying sick or safe leave protected by law.
  6. Failing to provide for accrued PTO: If you’ve implemented an unlimited PTO policy but some of your employees have accrued PTO balances, accrued PTO doesn’t just magically disappear when you implement the new policy. Depending on the state in which your company operates, you may be required to provide employees the opportunity to use accrued PTO or compensate employees for accrued but unused PTO.

Tips for avoiding unlimited PTO policy mistakes:

  • Sick leave rules: Ensure your policy complies with all applicable paid sick leave laws. Paid sick leave laws vary by state, county and city. Before finalizing the language of your unlimited PTO policy and related documentation, make sure you’re aware of and in compliance with all laws applicable to your employees.
  • Existing balances: If you’re converting from an accrued PTO policy, be sure to include a sentence or two addressing how accrued PTO will be handled going forward.

Unlimited PTO policy FAQs

Why might unlimited PTO be considered a trap?

Because unlimited PTO does not accrue, employees do not have a specific amount of PTO to which they’re entitled, which can lead employees to not take as much PTO as they might under a traditional PTO policy. Depending on how your policy is drafted and implemented, employees’ ability to take PTO may also hinge on their manager’s discretion. And, because unlimited PTO doesn’t accrue, employees won’t receive compensation for unused PTO when they leave your company. Draft your unlimited PTO policy thoughtfully, setting expectations as to the minimum amount of PTO employees should take, objective criteria for managers to follow when approving or denying PTO requests and making clear employees’ rights to take protected sick leave.

What are unlimited PTO rules?

Under an unlimited PTO policy, employees do not accrue a specific amount of PTO. Instead, employees request PTO and managers approve or deny those requests based on business needs such as team coverage and workload. Consider including in your unlimited PTO policy information on which employees are eligible to take PTO, how far in advance employees must request PTO, the minimum amount of PTO employees are expected to take and employees’ rights to take protected sick leave. Make sure your policy complies with all applicable paid sick leave and FMLA laws.

What is the downside to unlimited PTO?

Some downsides of unlimited PTO include employees not taking as much PTO as they might under a traditional PTO policy, PTO being more difficult to administer in jobs where employees work shifts or on an hourly basis and managers having the ability to approve or deny PTO requests, which can result in inconsistent administration of the policy. To minimize some of these downsides, set expectations as to the minimum amount of PTO employees should take and objective criteria for managers to follow when approving or denying PTO requests.

How much PTO is too much PTO?

Under a true unlimited PTO policy, there’s no such thing as too much PTO. Setting a cap on PTO can work against your company, particularly in states like California where unused vacation must be compensated. Managers should consider business needs, such as team coverage and workload, as well as fairness to other employees when deciding whether to approve or deny PTO requests. Employees taking extended leave due to a serious health condition or to bond with a new child should be steered toward your leave of absence policies.

Is unlimited PTO paid out?

Under a true unlimited PTO policy in which employees do not accrue PTO, the answer is generally no. In McPherson v. EF Intercultural Foundation (2020), the court interpreted the facts as indicating that the company’s PTO policy wasn’t unlimited and awarded payout for unused vacation.

Does unlimited PTO comply with paid sick leave laws?

Generally yes, as long as employees can take it for all the reasons covered under the applicable paid sick leave law and employers don’t deny employees leave that they’re legally entitled to take (e.g., requiring more documentation or advance notice than the law allows). In states that require employers to indicate the amount of paid sick leave available to employees on pay statements, employers can generally just write “unlimited.”

Can non-exempt employees have unlimited PTO?

Some employers require non-exempt employees to accrue PTO because it’s easier to administer for scheduling and coverage purposes and for timekeeping. That said, exempt employees are typically subject to unlimited PTO policies.

Can a manager deny unlimited PTO requests?

Employers can generally allow managers to approve or deny PTO requests (other than for reasons covered under applicable paid sick and safe leave laws) in accordance with business needs, employee coverage, and equitable treatment of employees (i.e., managers use the same criteria to decide whether to approve or deny PTO requests for all employees).

What happens to accrued PTO when you switch to unlimited PTO?

If employers switch from an accrued PTO policy to an unlimited PTO policy, employees’ previously accrued PTO doesn’t just disappear. Depending on the circumstances, employers may need to pay out accrued PTO (especially in states that require payout of accrued PTO at separation), allow employees to continue to take previously accrued PTO (sometimes referred to as a “legacy” PTO balance), or take some other action. Employers should consult with an attorney before making such a switch.

Do employees take more time off with unlimited PTO?

Some employees don’t take as much PTO when there’s no accrual to guide how much PTO they’ve earned. For this reason, employers with unlimited PTO policies often communicate recommended minimum amounts of PTO and monitor PTO usage to make sure employees are taking a reasonable amount of PTO.

How can Handbooks.io help you create an unlimited PTO policy?

Handbooks.io can help! Our unlimited PTO policy is included in our employee handbook product and customized for the state(s) in which you have employees. Our employee handbook product includes policies and procedures to help employers comply with federal, state, and local requirements and is created and maintained by U.S. employment attorneys.

Instead of trying to figure out how to word your unlimited PTO policy to comply with sick leave and PTO payout laws (particularly if you have employees in more than one state), we’ve already done that work for you. Plus, as laws change, we’ll make sure your policies are updated and compliant. And with our e-signature and employee acknowledgment tracking features, you’ll always know if and when employees received and acknowledged your policies – super helpful when rolling out a new unlimited PTO policy!

Best of all, our unlimited PTO policy will complement all of your other employee handbook policies (like our bereavement leave policy and remote work policy) so that your policies work together seamlessly. Over 25,000 businesses already use Handbooks.io – join them! Get started for free – no credit card required.

💡
Build your compliant handbook with Handbooks.io now!